URGENT UPDATE: Protests erupted today at the Hall of Justice in San Francisco, as demonstrators demand justice for the families of two women killed in a tragic hit-and-run incident nearly five years ago. The case involves Troy McAlister, who is facing charges for the deaths of 27-year-old Hanako Abe and 60-year-old Elizabeth Platt during a New Year’s Eve incident in 2020.
Protesters gathered this morning, holding signs bearing the images of the victims. “You had an individual who had committed 91 felonies and they had been let out repeatedly,” shouted Forrest Liu, a Stop Asian Hate activist. The urgency of today’s protest comes as McAlister’s attorney seeks to pursue a diversion program instead of traditional incarceration, despite the serious nature of the charges.
McAlister was allegedly driving a stolen vehicle and was on parole at the time of the incident. His attorney, Scott Grant of the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office, stated that today’s court appearance was for a receipt of an eligibility report from the Department of Public Health. “Research continuously shows that long-term structured treatment improves public safety over simple incarceration,” Grant argued, advocating for McAlister’s treatment for an underlying condition.
However, the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office has indicated that McAlister does not qualify for mental health diversion due to his DUI charge. Grant plans to challenge this position, emphasizing the need for accountability in cases of repeated offenses.
“We need to face consequences for escalating behavior,” said protester Liz Le, expressing frustration over the delays in seeking justice. The case has already played a pivotal role in the recall of former District Attorney Chesa Boudin, highlighting ongoing tensions regarding public safety and criminal justice in the city.
As tensions rise, protesters are threatening to initiate recall efforts against the judge presiding over McAlister’s case. The lack of transparency surrounding the proceedings has sparked further outrage, with demonstrators demanding more clarity in the judicial process.
The next significant court date is set for October 28, 2023, where a hearing on the motion for diversion will take place. The Public Defender’s Office has stated that they are still awaiting the treatment plan for McAlister, with expectations it will arrive by day’s end.
This developing story continues to resonate with the San Francisco community, as families and activists seek justice for the victims of this tragic incident. The emotional weight of loss is palpable, and the call for accountability remains urgent.
