UPDATE: A recent culinary tour of Portland, Maine, has unveiled the top five lobster rolls, igniting excitement among seafood lovers everywhere. The ranking showcases not just taste but also the stunning seaside atmospheres that define Maine’s iconic seafood experience.
During a visit earlier this month, July 15, 2023, the quest for the best lobster roll led to an array of flavors and prices, with most culinary delights exceeding $30. This price point may deter some of the millions of tourists flocking to Maine’s coastline each year, but for those seeking the ultimate lobster experience, the findings are crucial.
The first stop was the renowned Highroller Lobster Co., which has transformed from a hot-dog cart into a lobster roll institution. Located on Exchange Street, the establishment was recently awarded the best lobster roll by Portland Old Port. The customizable options were impressive, but the $30 Maine-style roll was noted for an overwhelming amount of mayonnaise, overshadowing the succulent lobster meat.
Next on the tour was the Portland Lobster Company, a Central Old Port hotspot recognized for its picturesque waterfront location and lively atmosphere. On a busy Saturday afternoon, I enjoyed a classic lobster roll with warm butter for $29.99. While the lobster’s flavor stood out, its texture was somewhat rubbery, making it a reliable choice but not extraordinary.
Then, I ventured to Bite Into Maine, which has garnered accolades as the best sandwich in Maine. Priced at $31.95, the 6-ounce lobster roll was dressed perfectly with mayonnaise on a butter-grilled bun, offering a delightful taste. However, the restaurant’s industrial vibe felt out of place for a classic Maine experience.
The highly recognizable Cousins Maine Lobster food truck, located at the base of the historic Portland Head Light, was temporarily closed during my visit. This food truck is known for its classic Maine-style roll, typically priced around $23.99. Despite the closure, the location remains a must-visit for tourists seeking a quintessential New England experience.
Finally, the culinary journey culminated at Luke’s Lobster, situated on Portland Pier and celebrated by locals as the best lobster roll in the area. Priced at $39, this hefty Maine-style roll came with a unique seasoning blend and generous portions of delectable lobster meat. The ambiance, stunning views, and overall presentation made it the standout choice in this culinary competition.
As summer tourism peaks, these rankings highlight the best places for lobster rolls in Portland, Maine. With prices and unique flavors varying widely, seafood enthusiasts are encouraged to try these iconic rolls before the season ends. For those planning a trip to Maine, stopping at these top-rated establishments is a must for an unforgettable lobster roll experience.
Stay tuned for more updates and rankings from Portland’s vibrant food scene!
