The Philadelphia Eagles’ recent triumph in Super Bowl LIX has sparked a lively debate among football enthusiasts. The Eagles didn’t just win; they dominated the Kansas City Chiefs with a resounding 41-22 victory. This performance, coupled with their earlier dismantling of the Washington Commanders in the conference title game, has led some to consider them one of the greatest teams in NFL history.
Among those singing the Eagles’ praises is Saquon Barkley, the reigning Offensive Player of the Year and a key player in their championship run. During a recent episode of the “Exciting Mics” podcast with fellow champions Cooper DeJean and Reed Blankenship, Barkley confidently stated that he “firmly believes” the 2024 Eagles deserve a place in the top five NFL teams of all time.
Analyzing the 2024 Eagles’ Claim to Greatness
Barkley’s assertion raises an intriguing question: Do the 2024 Eagles truly belong among the pantheon of NFL legends? While opinions vary, it’s essential to consider historical context and compare them to other iconic teams.
Historical Comparisons: The Top 5 NFL Teams
To evaluate the Eagles’ place in history, let’s examine some of the most celebrated teams:
- 1992 Dallas Cowboys: Known for their “Triplets” – Troy Aikman, Emmitt Smith, and Michael Irvin – this team boasted a formidable lineup that led them to a 13-3 finish and a decisive Super Bowl XXVII victory over the Buffalo Bills.
- 1984 San Francisco 49ers: Under Bill Walsh, the 49ers achieved a 15-1 record, with Joe Montana’s clutch performances culminating in a dominant Super Bowl win against the Miami Dolphins.
- 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers: Featuring 10 future Hall of Famers, the Steelers’ physicality and Terry Bradshaw’s MVP season propelled them to a Super Bowl XIII victory.
- 1985 Chicago Bears: Renowned for their suffocating defense, the Bears, led by Mike Ditka and Buddy Ryan, crushed the New England Patriots in Super Bowl XX.
- 1972 Miami Dolphins: The only team to achieve a perfect season, the Dolphins’ 17-0 record under Don Shula remains unmatched in NFL history.
Where Do the 2024 Eagles Stand?
While the Eagles’ recent success is undeniable, placing them among these legendary teams is contentious. A more reasonable ranking might place them between the 10th and 20th greatest teams of all time. The challenge lies in comparing teams from different eras, each with its unique style and strengths.
Recency bias can overshadow the accomplishments of past giants like the 1966 Green Bay Packers, who won the first Super Bowl, or the 1999 Los Angeles Rams, known as the “Greatest Show on Turf.” The Eagles’ ability to compete with such teams remains a topic of debate.
The Eagles’ 2024 Season in Context
The 2024 Eagles deserve recognition for their achievements. Barkley’s historic 2,000-yard rushing season, supported by an exceptional offensive line, was a standout performance. Quarterback Jalen Hurts excelled under pressure, and Vic Fangio’s defense effectively neutralized the Chiefs’ potent offense.
“By the end of the year, they felt inevitable, and the results bore that out.”
Their victory was not just about talent; it was about delivering when it mattered most. The Eagles’ first Super Bowl win in 2017 was a tale of overcoming adversity, while their latest triumph was a testament to their dominance.
Looking Ahead: The Legacy of the 2024 Eagles
While the debate over their place in history continues, the 2024 Eagles have undoubtedly left their mark. They may not be universally accepted as a top-five team, but their achievements warrant acknowledgment among the NFL’s elite.
As discussions persist, the Eagles’ legacy will be shaped by future performances and the evolving narrative of NFL greatness. For now, they stand as a formidable force that captured the imagination of fans and players alike.
