The latest adaptation of the horror classic, I Know What You Did Last Summer, premiered on streaming platforms, but it has not captured the audience’s attention as hoped. This reboot, which follows a similar premise to the original 1997 film, features a group of friends grappling with the aftermath of a tragic accident that leads to a murder. Despite its nostalgic ties, the film struggles to deliver compelling characters or genuine scares.
In this new iteration, the story opens with a group of friends on a secluded coastal road. Their fun takes a dark turn when an accident results in a death. The group, including good-natured Ava (played by Chase Sui Wonders) and the self-centered Danica (portrayed by Madelyn Cline), initially decides to conceal the incident. A year later, they gather for Danica’s wedding to newcomer Wyatt (played by Joshua Orpin). However, the past resurfaces when Danica receives an ominous note featuring the film’s titular message.
As the plot unfolds, the friends find themselves targeted by a killer donning the familiar fisherman’s attire. The tension escalates when a murder occurs, reigniting their collective guilt over the previous year’s events. The film employs familiar horror tropes, including a local pastor, played by Austin Nichols, who raises suspicions, and a true-crime podcaster, Gabbriette Bechtel, who investigates the town’s dark history of similar murders.
Despite the film’s attempts to leverage nostalgia by featuring original cast members such as Jennifer Love Hewitt and Freddie Prinze Jr., their roles do not elevate the film sufficiently. They contribute to the story but do not provide the anticipated thrill that fans of the genre might expect.
Critics have pointed out that the film relies heavily on its predecessors’ reputation rather than offering fresh perspectives or innovative storytelling. While the original film had its share of jump scares and memorable moments, this reboot fails to deliver similar excitement or depth, leaving audiences feeling underwhelmed.
The film does manage to generate some light moments, especially in its attempts to mislead viewers by painting minor characters as potential suspects. Yet, the overall experience does not warrant a viewing for those unfamiliar with the original.
As the summer horror season continues, I Know What You Did Last Summer may serve as a reminder of what the genre can achieve, but it ultimately leaves viewers wanting more. With its lack of originality and engaging content, it seems unlikely to resonate with either fans of the original or newcomers to the franchise.
