The latest episode of HBO Max’s “And Just Like That” prompts a critical look at the show’s treatment of Carrie Bradshaw, portrayed by Sarah Jessica Parker. In this continuation of the iconic “Sex and the City” franchise, Carrie grapples with her relationships while seemingly avoiding the opportunity to embrace singlehood. This article explores why the narrative confines her to a romantic pursuit instead of allowing her to explore independence.
In a recent episode, Carrie reflects on her writing project, a novel set in 1846, during a moment of inspiration. Yet, her tranquility is disrupted by a sudden invasion of rats, symbolizing the chaos in her romantic life. Despite her wealth and independence, Carrie remains entangled in her relationship with Aidan Shaw (John Corbett), who is emotionally and physically distant, complicating her journey of self-discovery.
“And Just Like That” continues to mirror the essence of its predecessor while wrestling with contemporary themes. The main characters, including Miranda Hobbes (Cynthia Nixon) and Charlotte York (Kristin Davis), have settled into stable relationships, contrasting with Carrie’s ongoing romantic turmoil. This dynamic raises questions about the portrayal of single women in midlife, particularly as statistics indicate that 29.1 percent of U.S. adults aged 30-49 have never been married, according to the National Center for Family & Marriage Research.
Carrie’s reluctance to fully embrace her single status is evident. The show introduces a new character, Duncan (Jonathan Cake), her downstairs neighbor, who potentially symbolizes a fresh romantic interest. Their connection hints at a classic romantic comedy trope—two people who initially dislike each other growing closer. However, Carrie’s established relationship with Aidan overshadows this budding attraction, leaving audiences to wonder if she will ever truly explore life on her own terms.
The narrative also reflects broader societal trends. Many women in Carrie’s demographic find empowerment in their independence. According to the Pew Research Center, 38 percent of single women in the U.S. are actively dating, compared to 61 percent of single men. This data suggests a shift in how women view relationships, yet the show seems hesitant to fully embrace this evolution.
In a recent episode titled “They Wanna Have Fun,” Carrie orchestrates a birthday celebration for Charlotte, with Miranda helping to manage the festivities. During the event, Miranda raises concerns about Carrie’s commitment to Aidan, highlighting the emotional labor women often undertake in relationships. Carrie’s defensive response underscores her internal struggle, as she clings to a complicated relationship rather than exploring her independence.
The presence of Aidan looms large throughout the series, though his character often appears absent. His inability to support Carrie during her time of need raises questions about their compatibility. As Carrie navigates her feelings, the show hints at a potential shift in the narrative, suggesting that she may soon explore a connection with Duncan.
The evolving dynamics between Carrie and Duncan point to the show’s potential to redefine its protagonist’s journey. The two share a creative bond, exchanging drafts of their writing—a metaphor for vulnerability and intimacy. Yet, Carrie’s historical pattern of pursuing emotionally unavailable partners may hinder her growth.
As Carrie continues to navigate her relationships, the audience is left hoping for a storyline that prioritizes her personal journey over romantic entanglements. The potential for a new chapter, one that allows her to choose herself instead of seeking validation through others, remains tantalizingly close yet frustratingly out of reach.
In a time when many women are redefining their identities outside of traditional relationship norms, “And Just Like That” faces the challenge of allowing Carrie to break free from the cycle of dependency. While the series offers glimpses of transformation, it remains to be seen if it will grant its heroine the agency to forge her own path.
New episodes of “And Just Like That” stream every Thursday on HBO Max. As viewers continue to engage with Carrie’s story, the hope for a more independent and self-assured protagonist grows stronger.
