In a candid conversation on the new dating show, Are You My First?, Kaitlyn Bristowe opened up about her first sexual experience, revealing that it was “scary, painful and terrible.” This personal account was shared during a game segment with her co-host, Colton Underwood, as they discussed their journeys through love and intimacy.
Colton, 33, posed the question, “How would you describe your first time in three words?” Kaitlyn, 40, did not hesitate in her response. Her honesty resonated with viewers as she shared the uncomfortable truths of her experience, which occurred on a couch that had been handed down from her sister, a remnant of their parents’ divorce. “Honestly, [it was like a] horror film, and I say this with love,” she remarked, reflecting on her teenage years and her relationship with her high school sweetheart.
During the discussion, Kaitlyn also mentioned her struggles with vaginismus, a condition that can cause involuntary contractions of the vaginal muscles, resulting in pain during penetration. Although she did not elaborate on how this condition impacted her first sexual encounter, she emphasized that it was not the romantic moment she had envisioned. “It’s messy, but so is love,” she advised, providing perspective for those who may be experiencing similar challenges.
Insights from a Dating Show
Colton and Kaitlyn, both well-known figures in Bachelor Nation, are now guiding contestants on Hulu’s latest dating show, which aims to explore the nuances of virginity and intimate relationships. Colton, who was a virgin during his season as The Bachelor, shared that the show’s goal is not solely about sexual encounters but rather about forging meaningful connections. “The goal is to connect with somebody, to experience these things,” he stated.
The show also encourages participants to engage in self-discovery. Colton noted that many contestants gained a deeper understanding of their virginity and personal acceptance throughout the experience. “On a deeper level, I think some of the cast experienced the first self-love and self-acceptance,” he expressed, highlighting the emotional journey they undertook.
As Kaitlyn and Colton continue to share their insights, viewers are drawn into the raw and unfiltered discussions surrounding first experiences. The dynamic between the two hosts offers a balance of humor and sincerity, making the show relatable to a wide audience.
Streaming Now
“The goal of the show was never to get them laid,”
Colton remarked, emphasizing the importance of genuine relationships. As Are You My First? continues to air, it provides a platform for young adults to navigate the complexities of romance and personal growth in today’s dating landscape.
The series is currently available for streaming on Hulu, inviting viewers to explore the themes of first times and the lessons that accompany them. As Kaitlyn and Colton share their stories, they encourage others to embrace the unpredictable journey of love and intimacy.
