Human remains discovered nearly three decades ago at Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, Indiana, have been positively identified as those of Roger Goodlet, according to an announcement by Hamilton County Coroner Jeff Jellison on Tuesday. This identification was confirmed through DNA testing conducted by the University of North Texas Center for Human Identification. The analysis supports an initial identification made through dental records in 1996.
Coroner Jellison emphasized the importance of this confirmation, stating, “Today’s confirmation provides an opportunity for continued closure to the family and loved ones of Roger Goodlet.” He noted that while the case has profoundly affected the community for decades, advancements in forensic science have finally enabled authorities to restore names to victims.
Goodlet was reported missing from Indianapolis in 1994 and is believed to be one of several victims of suspected serial killer Herb Baumeister. Baumeister owned Fox Hollow Farm when authorities discovered over 10,000 bone and bone fragments scattered throughout the property in 1996. He fled law enforcement and subsequently died by suicide before he could be apprehended.
The identification of Goodlet adds to the growing list of victims linked to this case. To date, officials have positively identified ten victims from the site. The Hamilton County Coroner’s Office plans to continue its collaboration with local and federal agencies, alongside private forensic experts, to analyze and identify additional remains uncovered at the property.
The long-standing mystery of Fox Hollow Farm illustrates the complexities of forensic investigations and the passage of time. Each breakthrough offers a glimmer of hope for families seeking closure. As forensic technology continues to evolve, it may yet unravel more truths hidden within the remnants of this tragic case.
